Pyunkang Yul vs Skin1004 — side by side, no bias.
Our pick
Essence Toner
9/10 · Pyunkang Yul
| Essence Toner | Madagascar Centella Tone Brightening Toner | |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Pyunkang Yul | Skin1004 |
| Category | toner | toner |
| Editor Rating | 9/10 ★ | 7.5/10 |
| Category | toner | toner |
| Texture | Viscous, slightly thick essence-toner hybrid | Lightweight, slightly milky liquid |
| Finish | deeply hydrated, plumped | hydrated, bright |
| Skin Types |
| Targets |
| Pros |
|
|
| Cons |
|
|
| Verdict | Seven ingredients. That is the entire formula. And it works better than toners with fifty. The 91% astragalus root extract provides deep, lasting hydration with anti-inflammatory benefits that calm reactive skin on contact. The viscous texture layers beautifully — apply 2-3 skins and your face feels like it drank a glass of water. This is the toner that proved K-beauty minimalism is not a compromise. A desert island product for many skincare enthusiasts. | A functional toner that pairs centella with niacinamide for a soothing-meets-brightening approach. The niacinamide addition gives this an edge over the pure centella ampoule for those concerned about dullness or uneven tone. It's well-formulated for its price point, though the brightening effect is subtle — you'll need consistent use over weeks to notice a difference. A good daily toner for sensitive skin that wants gentle brightening without irritation. |
