Brand Comparison
Mario Badescu vs Papa Recipe
A head-to-head comparison of two popular K-beauty brands. Which one is right for your skin?
Our Pick
Papa Recipe
Higher editor rating (8.6 vs 7.6)
Mario Badescu
Mario Badescu Skin Care is the New York dermatology institution that built the iconic Drying Lotion in the 1960s and has sold roughly the same product line, in roughly the same packaging, ever since. Romanian aesthetician Mario Badescu opened his Manhattan facial salon in 1967, formulated his own products for clients, and accidentally built one of the longest-running indie skincare brands in the US. The Drying Lotion (salicylic acid + sulfur + zinc oxide settled at the bottom of a glass bottle, dabbed onto pimples with a Q-tip) remains the brand's #1 best-seller and one of the most iconic spot treatments in skincare history. The Facial Sprays (Aloe, Herbs & Rosewater; Cucumber, Green Tea & Aloe) are cult-following beloved despite being fragrance-heavy and arguably unnecessary. Best for spot treatments and the Drying Lotion specifically; the rest of the line is a mixed bag of effective and dated. Cheap enough to experiment with, iconic enough to keep on the shelf.
Pros
- ✓ Drying Lotion is a 60-year cult acne icon that genuinely works on whiteheads
- ✓ Sephora-exclusive availability with consistent stocking
- ✓ broad budget-friendly range covers most concerns
- ✓ NYC family-owned heritage with continuous formulation
Cons
- ✗ fragrance-heavy across the entire line
- ✗ many formulations feel dated (alcohol-forward toners, heavy creams)
- ✗ marketing is uneven — some products work brilliantly, others underwhelm
- ✗ has been sued multiple times for hidden steroid contamination in older formulations (resolved)
Papa Recipe
Papa Recipe is the quiet Korean family-run brand behind the Bombee Honey Mask Pack — the sheet mask your friend brought back from Seoul in 2016 that made you reconsider what a sheet mask could be. The lineup leans on manuka honey, propolis, and royal jelly; the packaging is unfussy; the masks genuinely work. Not the flashiest brand on the shelf, but the one your Korean aunt actually uses.
